Using `non_exhaustive` as well as a public inner field is incorrect, it
prohibits users from creating or matching on the error and does not
achieve forward comparability.
This was never right, we shouldn't have done it.
The errors `SegwitV0Error` and `LegacyScripthashError` contained only
one variant - out of range. There will not be a new one in the future so
this change flattens it to simplify.
The hadnling of `io::Error` in sighash had a few problems:
* It used `io::ErrorKind` instead of `io::Error` losing inforation
* Changing `io::ErrorKind` to `io::Error` would disable `PartialEq`&co
* The `Io` error wariants were duplicated
It turns out all of these can be solved by moving the `Io` variant into
a separate error.
Applies to both `ecdsa::Signature` and `taproot::Signature`.
Re-name the `Signature` fields with more descriptive names. The
names used were decided upon in the issue discussion.
Impove rustdocs while we are at it.
Note, the change to `sign-tx-segwit-v0` is refactor only, the diff does
not show it but we have a local variable already called `sighash_type`
that is equal to `EcdsaSighashType::All`.
Includes a function argument rename as well, just to be uniform.
Fix: #2139
There is no advantage in having `io::Read` as opposed to `Read` and
importing the trait. It is surprising that we do so.
Remove `io::` path from `io::Read` and `io::Write`. Some docs keep the
path, leave them as is. Add import `use io::{Read, Write}`.
Refactor only, no logic changes.
Generic types can be single letters, and a writer is conventionally, in
this codebase at least, called `W`.
Use `W` instead of `Write` with no loss of clarity.
Recently during the rust-bitcoin workshop at TABConf devs were thrown
off by the example on `witness_mut`.
Attempt to improve the docs on `witness_mut`.
Since we are no longer relying on the blanket `io::Write` impl for
`&mut io::Write`, we should now ensure that we do not require
`Sized` for our `io::Write` bounds, as its unnecessarily
restrictive and can no longer be worked around by simply adding an
`&mut`.
`std::io::Write` is implemented for all `&mut std::io::Write`. This
makes it easy to have APIs that mix and match owned `Write`s with
mutable references to `Write`s.
However, in the next commit we add our own `Write` trait which we
intend to implement for all `std::io::Write`. Sadly, this is
mutually exclusive with a blanket implementation on our own
`&mut Write`, as that would conflict with an `std::io::Write`
blanket impl.
Thus, in order to use the `Write for all &mut Write` blanket impl
in rust-bitcoin, we'd have to bound all `Write`s by
`std::io::Write`, as we're unable to provide a blanket
`Write for &mut Write` impl.
Here we stop relying on that blanket impl in order to introduce the
new trait in the next commit.
Done as part of the great error clean up.
Currently we are returning a general `Error` from `Prevouts` functions,
this is un-informative, we can do better by returning specific types
that indicate the exact error path.
We have a new API function available with recent version of `secp256k1`
to create a `Message` directly from a sighash byte array.
Use `Message::from_digest(sighash.to_byte_array())` to construct
messages ready to sign.
Upgrade the `secp256k1` dependency to the newly released `v0.28.0`.
FTR this includes two simple changes:
- Use `Message::from_digest_slice` instead of `Message::from_slice`.
- Use `secp256k1::Keypair` instead of `secp256k1::KeyPair`.
8eff4d0385 Remove private hex test macro (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
We have this macro in `hex-conservative` now, remove the version here.
This patch does not change the public API and only touches test code.
ACKs for top commit:
apoelstra:
ACK 8eff4d0385
clarkmoody:
ACK 8eff4d0385
Tree-SHA512: 93a08fff778930071cd1a28c19202e4a94ca8881b2e873538de2e942b71c2cd6184ed6364c572538a8a699295a71761c6f836accaf251a15683138b71f148fab
On our way to v1.0.0 we are defining a standard for our error types,
this includes:
- Uses the following derives (unless not possible, usually because of `io::Error`)
`#[derive(Debug, Clone, PartialEq, Eq)]`
- Has `non_exhaustive` unless we really know we can commit to not adding
anything.
Furthermore, we are trying to make the codebase easy to read. Error code
is write-once-read-many (well it should be) so if we make all the error
code super uniform the users can flick to an error and quickly see what
it includes. In an effort to achieve this I have made up a style and
over recent times have change much of the error code to that new style,
this PR audits _all_ error types in the code base and enforces the
style, specifically:
- Is layed out: definition, [impl block], Display impl, error::Error impl, From impls
- `error::Error` impl matches on enum even if it returns `None` for all variants
- Display/Error impls import enum variants locally
- match uses *self and `ref e`
- error::Error variants that return `Some` come first, `None` after
Re: non_exhaustive
To make dev and review easier I have added `non_exhaustive` to _every_
error type. We can then remove it error by error as we see fit. This is
because it takes a bit of thinking to do and review where as this patch
should not take much brain power to review.
We would like the codebase to be optimized for readability not ease of
development, as such code that is write-once-read-many should not use
macros.
Currently we use the `impl_std_error` macro to implement
`std::error::Error` for struct error types. This makes the code harder
to read at a glance because one has to think what the macro does.
Remove the `impl_std_error` macro and write the code explicitly.
There is no logical default for the transaction version number, there is
only pre-bip68 (v1) and post-bip68 (v2). Uses should specify the version
they want not rely on us making the choice.
(I originally added this impl to support testing, this was in hindsight
the wrong thing to do, props to Sanket for noticing.)
BIP-68 activated a fair while ago (circa 2019) and since then only
transaction versions 1 and 2 have been considered standard.
Currently in our `Transaction` struct we use an `i32`, this means users
can construct a non-standard transaction if they do not first look up
what the value should be. We can help folk out here by abstracting over
the version number.
Since the version number only governs standardness elect to make the
inner `i32` public (ie., not an invariant). The aim of the type is to
make life easy not restrict what versions are used.
Add transaction::Version data type that simply provides two consts `ONE`
and `TWO`.
Add a `Default` impl on `Version` that returns `Version::TWO`.
In tests that used version 0, instead use `Version::default` because the
test obviously does not care.
Recently we deprecated the `segwit_signature_hash` function but during
development the deprecation notice got stale.
Fix deprecation notice to use the actual function names.
The `ThirtyTwoByteHash` trait is defined in `secp256k1` and used in
`hashes` as well as `bitcoin`. This means that we must use the same
version of `hashes` in both `bitcoin` and `secp256k1`. This makes doing
release difficult.
Remove usage of `ThirtyTwoByteHash` and use `Message::from_slice`.
Include TODO above each usage because as soon as we release the new
version of secp we can use the new `Message::from_digest`.
This is step backwards as far as type safety goes and it makes the code
more ugly as well because it uses `expect` but thems the breaks.
The word "segwit" refers to segwit v0 and taproot but currently we have
`segwit_signature_hash` that is version specific (segwit v0).
- Rename `segwit_encode_signing_data_to` to
`segwit_v0_encode_signing_data_to`
- Add `p2wpkh_signature_hash` and `p2wsh_signature_hash` functions
We keep the single encode function because the error handling is better
that way.
While we are at it test the bip-143 test vectors against all the
sighash types of wrapped p2wsh.
50ada8298f Move EncodeSigningDataResult to sighash module (Tobin C. Harding)
1b7dc51ccb Remove deprecated code (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
We only keep deprecated code around for one release so we can now remove code deprecated in v0.30.0
Done in preparation as we gear up for v0.31.0 release.
ACKs for top commit:
apoelstra:
ACK 50ada8298f
sanket1729:
ACK 50ada8298f
Tree-SHA512: 40769258605563e2e12a6118306655fc9a012ae1f86509fca757ca411f0cef74480b7bb7b0db147f30a7d362b8494a077d5ec04f719351661ceb5a0697a5369d
3c0bb63423 Do trivial rustdoc improvements (Tobin C. Harding)
3225aa9556 Use defensive documentation (Tobin C. Harding)
80d5d6665a crypto: key: Move error code to the bottom of the file (Tobin C. Harding)
fe3b1e1140 Move From for Error impl (Tobin C. Harding)
5f8e0ad67e Fix docs on error type (Tobin C. Harding)
f23155aa16 Do not capitalize error messages (Tobin C. Harding)
ae07786c27 Add InvalidSighashTypeError (Tobin C. Harding)
baba0fde57 Put NonStandardSighashTypeError inside ecdsa::Error variant (Tobin C. Harding)
6c9d9d9c36 Improve error display imlps (Tobin C. Harding)
22c7aa8808 Rename non standard sighash error type (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
EDIT: The commit hashes below are stale but the text is valid still.
In an effort to "perfect" our error handling, overhaul the error handling in the `crypto` module.
The aim is to do a small chunk so we can bikeshed on it then I can apply the learnings to the rest of the codebase.
Its all pretty trivial except:
- commit `4c180277 Put NonStandardSighashTypeError inside ecdsa::Error variant`
- comimt `5a196535 Add InvalidSighashTypeError`
- commit `05772ade Use defensive documentation`
Particularly the last one might be incorrect/controversial.
Also, please take the time to check the overall state of error code in the `crypto` module on this branch in case there is anything else we want to do.
Thanks
ACKs for top commit:
apoelstra:
ACK 3c0bb63423
Tree-SHA512: 7e5f8590aec5826098d4d8d33351a41b10c42b6379ff86e5b889e73271b71921fc3ca9525baa5da53e07fa2e961e710393694e04658a8243799950b4604caf43
The `network` module deals with data types and logic related to
internetworking bitcoind nodes, this is commonly referred to as the p2p
layer.
Rename the `network` module to `p2p` and fix all the paths.
As we do for `NonStandardSighashErrorType` add an error struct for
invalid sighash type, used by the `taproot` module instead of returning
a generic error enum with loads of unused variants.
Error types conventionally include `Error` as a suffix.
Rename `NonStandardSighashType` to `NonStandardSighashTypeError`.
While we are at it make the inner type private to the crate, there is no
need to leak the inner values type.
As part of an ongoing effort to make our error types stable and useful
add a stand set of derives to all error types in the library.
`#[derive(Debug, Clone, PartialEq, Eq)]`
Add `Copy` if possible and the error type does not include
`#[non_exhaustive]`.
If an error type includes `io::Error` it only gets `#[derive(Debug)]`.
This type was defined in the `transaction` module because it was
originally used in a function that had been deprecated in favour of
moving the logic to the `sighash` module.
We just removed the deprecated code so we can now move this type to the
`sighash` module where it is used.
We have just released the `hex-conservative` crate, we can now use it.
Do the following:
- Depend on `hex-conservative` in `bitcoin` and `hashes`
- Re-export `hex-conservative` as `hex` from both crate roots.
- Remove all the old hex code from `hashes`
- Fix all the import statements (makes up the bulk of the lines changed
in this patch)
The `empty` constructor is mis-named for the following reasons:
- Non-uniform with `ScriptBuf::new`
- Non-standard with respect to stdlib which uses `Path::new` and
`PathBuf::new` (on which we based the `Scritp`/`ScriptBuf`)
Rename the function to `new`, put it at the top of the impl block while
we are at it.
Previous changes enabled passing the string used as a tag into
`sha256t_hash_newtype!` macro rather than hard-coding midstate. This
commit takes advantage of it and replaces the hard-coded values with
compile-time executed (`const`) hashing.
The Rust API guidelines state that macros should be evocative of the
output, which is a sensible recommendation. We already had this for
`hash_newtype!` macro but didn't for sha256t version.
This changes the macro to have this syntax:
```rust
sha256t_hash_newtype! {
// Order of these structs is fixed.
/// Optional documentation details here. Summary is auto-generated.
/*pub*/ struct Tag = raw(MIDSTATE_BYTES, LEN);
/// Documentation here
#[hash_newtype(forward)] // optional, default is backward
/*pub*/ struct HashType(/* attributes allowed here */ _);
}
```
Closes#1427
If we use `#![cfg_attr(docsrs, feature(doc_auto_cfg))]` instead of
`#![cfg_attr(docsrs, feature(doc_cfg))]` we no longer need to manually
mark types with `#[cfg_attr(docsrs, doc(cfg(feature = "std")))]`.
Sweeeeeet.
Liam Aharon
Tobin C. Harding
Martin Habovstiak
Matt Corallo
Steven Roose
Andrew Poelstra
yancy