57dd6739c3 Do not print error when displaying for std builds (Tobin C. Harding)
b80cfeed85 Bind to error_kind instead of e (Tobin C. Harding)
241ec72497 Bind to b instead of e (Tobin C. Harding)
01f481bf5c Bind to s instead of e (Tobin C. Harding)
5c6d369289 network: Remove unused error variants (Tobin C. Harding)
e67e97bb37 Put From impl below std::error::Error impl (Tobin C. Harding)
6ca98e5275 Remove error TODO (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
As part of the ongoing error improvement work and as a direct result of [this comment](https://github.com/rust-bitcoin/rust-bitcoin/pull/987#issuecomment-1135563287) improve the `Display` implementations of all our error types so as to not repeat the source error when printing.
The first 5 patches are trivial clean ups around the errors. Patch 6 is the real work.
EDIT: ~CC @Kixunil, have I got the right idea here bro?~ Patch 6 now includes a macro as suggested.
ACKs for top commit:
Kixunil:
ACK 57dd6739c3
apoelstra:
ACK 57dd6739c3
sanket1729:
ACK 57dd6739c3. Did not check if we covered all cases. We need to remember to use `write_err!` instead of `write!` in future.
Tree-SHA512: 1ed26b0cc5f9a0f71684c431cbb9f94404c116c9136be696434c56a2f56fd93cb5406b0955edbd0dc6f8612e77345c93fa70a70650118968cc58e680333a41de
2e7effc604 Feature `use-serde` renamed to `serde` (Martin Habovstiak)
Pull request description:
Features activating external crates are supposed to have same name as
those crates. However we depend on same feature in other crates so we
need a separate feature. After MSRV bump it is possible to rename the
crates and features so we can now fix this inconsistency.
Sadly, derive can't see that the crate was renamed so all derives must
be told to use the other one.
Replaces #373
ACKs for top commit:
apoelstra:
ACK 2e7effc604
Tree-SHA512: b20364b9e8f30c2269bef915e821b2b2ec929e71dd0e88af2bc3a021821f87011d35e095cb8efe99add77a23dde940a17537eb387fb4582b05c57c8679969eb0
99f565f932 Add non_exhaustive to all error enums (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
Adding an error variant to a public enum is an API breaking change, this means making, what could be, small refactorings or improvements harder. If we use `non_exhaustive` for error types then we mitigate this cost.
There is a tradeoff however, downstream users who explicitly match on our public error types must include a wildcard pattern.
ACKs for top commit:
apoelstra:
ACK 99f565f932
Kixunil:
ACK 99f565f932
Tree-SHA512: ff329f87d52b3fbe24654f32e4062ddae73173cba5a13d511591158e68ee278e9bdc0a70a3e0b42d6606b369255923f9c46d8b3d1b2ff75f8461a82567df80cd
5fbb211085 Use fn name to_ instead of as_ (Tobin Harding)
8ffa32315d Use fn name to_ instead of into_ (Tobin Harding)
6874ce91e2 Remove as_inner (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
Rust has naming conventions surrounding conversion functions
We have a handful of methods that are not following convention. This PR is done as three patches, separated by incorrect function name (`into_` or `as_`) and by whether or not the original method needs deprecating. Can be squashed if folks prefer.
From the docs: https://rust-lang.github.io/api-guidelines/naming.html
<h2><a class="header" href="https://rust-lang.github.io/api-guidelines/naming.html#ad-hoc-conversions-follow-as_-to_-into_-conventions-c-conv" id="ad-hoc-conversions-follow-as_-to_-into_-conventions-c-conv">Ad-hoc conversions follow <code>as_</code>, <code>to_</code>, <code>into_</code> conventions (C-CONV)</a></h2>
<p>Conversions should be provided as methods, with names prefixed as follows:</p>
Prefix | Cost | Ownership
-- | -- | --
as_ | Free | borrowed -> borrowed
to_ | Expensive | borrowed -> borrowed
| | | borrowed -> owned (non-Copy types)
| | | owned -> owned (Copy types)
into_ | Variable | owned -> owned (non-Copy types)
EDIT: I did actually audit all uses of `to_` when I first did this, I did this by grepping for `fn to_` and checking the output against the table.
ACKs for top commit:
apoelstra:
ACK 5fbb211085
Kixunil:
ACK 5fbb211085
Tree-SHA512: f750b2d1a10bc1d4bb030d8528a582701cc3d615aa8a8ab391324dae639544bb3629a19b372784e1e274a8ddcc613c621c7aae21a3ea54fde356a6aa5e611ac0
Adding an error variant to a public enum is an API breaking change, this
means making what could be small refactorings or improvements harder. If
we use `non_exhaustive` for error types then we mitigate this cost.
There is a tradeoff however, downstream users who explicitly match on
our public error types must include a wildcard pattern.
Rust convention is to use `to_` for conversion methods that convert from
an owned type to an owned `Copy` type. `into_` is for owned to owned
non-`Copy` types.
Re-name and deprecate conversion methods that use `into_` for `Copy`
types to use `to_`.
`self` and the referenced type returned by `as_inner` are both `Copy`
types. There is no need to provide an reference getter method to a
`Copy` type since implementing `Copy` implies that copying is cheap.
We implement `source` for all our error types. This means that we should
not display the source error explicitly because users can call `source`
to get the source error.
However, `std::Error::source()` is only available for "std" builds, so
that we do not loose the error source information in "no-std" builds add
a macro that conditionally adds the source onto the error message.
Features activating external crates are supposed to have same name as
those crates. However we depend on same feature in other crates so we
need a separate feature. After MSRV bump it is possible to rename the
crates and features so we can now fix this inconsistency.
Sadly, derive can't see that the crate was renamed so all derives must
be told to use the other one.
Clippy emits:
warning: this expression creates a reference which is immediately
dereferenced by the compiler
As suggested, remove the additional reference.
Use cargo to upgrade from edition 2015 to edition 2018.
cargo fix --edition
No manual changes made. The result of the command above is just to fix
all the use statements (add `crate::`) and fix the fully qualified path
formats i.e., `::Foo` -> `crate::Foo`.
Our usage of `SigHash` implies that 'sighash' is _two_ words; 'sighash'
is a well known word in the Bitcoin ecosystem it should appear in
identifiers as `Sighash`.
Rename `SchnorrSigHashType` to `SchnorrSighashType`.
Update our `rust-secp256k1` dependency to the latest version.
Requires doing:
- Add a new variant to `Error` for the case where parity of the internal
key is an invalid value (not 0 or 1).
- Use non-deprecated const
Rust convention is to use `to_` for conversion methods that convert from
an owned type to an owned `Copy` type. `into_` is for owned to owned
non-`Copy` types.
Re-name conversion methods that use `into_` for `Copy` types to use
`to_`, no need to deprecate these ones because they are unreleased.
Currently we calculate the parity during `tap_tweak` but do not return
it, this means others must re-do work done inside `tap_tweak` in order
to calculate the parity. We can just return the parity along with the
tweaked key.
Keeping inline with the method on `UntweakedPublicKey` that outputs a
`TweakedPublicKey` we can use the same name, for the same reasons.
Use `dangerous_assume_tweaked` as the constructor name to highlight the
fact that this constructor should probably not be being used.
We currently run `tweak_add_check` and use the result as a conditional
branch, the error path of which uses `unreachable`. This usage of
`unreachable` is non-typical. An 'unreachable' statement is by
definition supposed to be unreachable, it is not clear why we would need
to have a conditional branch to check an unreachable statement.
Use `debug_assert!` so programmer errors get caught in un-optimised
builds but in optimised builds the call to `tweak_add_check` is not even
done.
Ambiguous TweakedPublicKey and UntweakedPublicKey type aliases and methods to convert
Use structs for Untweaked and Tweaked key type
swap dangerous api to work on tweaked keys
remove unecessary allocations and rename methods
Use type alias for UntweakedPublicKey
TweakedPublicKey::new(...) method added
minor naming and doc changes
Docs can always do with a bit of love.
Clean up the module level (`//!`) rustdocs for all public modules.
I claim uniform is better than any specific method/style. I tried to fit
in with what ever was either most sane of most prevalent, therefore
attaining uniformity without unnecessary code churn (one exception being
the changes to headings described below).
Notes:
* Headings - use heading as a regular sentence for all modules e.g.,
```
//! Bitcoin network messages.
```
as opposed to
```
//! # Bitcoin Network Messages
```
It was not clear which style to use so I picked a 'random' mature
project and copied their style.
* Added 'This module' in _most_ places as the start of the module
description, however I was not religious about this one.
* Fixed line length if necessary since most of our code seems to follow
short (80 char) line lengths for comments anyways.
* Added periods and fixed obvious (and sometimes not so obvious)
grammatically errors.
* Added a trailing `//!` to every block since this was almost universal
already. I don't really like this one but I'm guessing it is Andrew's
preferred style since its on the copyright notices as well.
sanket1729
Andrew Poelstra
Tobin C. Harding
Martin Habovstiak
Dr Maxim Orlovsky
Jeremy Rubin
Noah
Noah Lanson