Recently we merged `commit 53d4fe66b57c255086def2b5e47afaddee776b75` to
fix CI even though a better approach is to use `'_` because it assists
reading the code (shows that the bit stream writer is not writing from a
reference since its writing a `Copy` type `n`).
Add back in the `'_` (I forget what its called).
877f9af364 Add new hex parse error variant (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
Recently we used an error type that holds only one expected hex string length when parsing but for `PublicKey`s we have two (66 and 130). Add a new error variant to express the error. Requires adding a variant to `bip32` for the same thing.
Fix: #1281
ACKs for top commit:
Kixunil:
ACK 877f9af364
apoelstra:
ACK 877f9af364
Tree-SHA512: c1ca493ee30418bd82bc326b35c18731260e4217c371f37301a73c64f9a6631163801acc217c6c2c7b14f632a2ad5043174266c1b4fdce127698e68ab8494f20
3c0598b399 Add standard constants to lock times (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
Some of the lock time structs (`Height`, `Time` ect.) are missing standard constants for min, max ect.
Add standard constants taking into consideration the various locktime corner cases.
Add `max_value` and `min_value` to be consistent with Rust 1.41.1 (incl. `Sequence`).
Fix: #1451
This PR is not complex in itself but **locktimes are notoriously complex, please wait for 3 acks before merging** - and ack'ing makes no guarantee that reviewer got all corner cases :)
There is no rush on this one, apoelstra, Kixunil, sanket1729 please just review when your brain is fresh.
ACKs for top commit:
apoelstra:
ACK 3c0598b399
Kixunil:
ACK 3c0598b399
Tree-SHA512: aa3d112db83b4785edb0a7a517cc335ded59f5967eb39b8979a6d68f9bba4644a27e5ca400fcabf368a1f8c0eecdef0b87b1011933ac7fd96b467b8501533203
Recently we used an error type that holds only one expected hex string
length when parsing but for `PublicKey`s we have two (66 and 130). Add a
new error variant to express the error. Requires adding a variant to
`bip32` for the same thing.
Fix: #1281
Some of the lock time structs (`Height`, `Time` ect.) are missing
standard constants for min, max ect.
Add standard constants taking into consideration the various locktime
corner cases.
Add `max_value` and `min_value` to be consistent with Rust 1.41.1 (incl.
`Sequence`).
Fix: #1451
a762a89b48 Add documentation to Sequence::is_final (Tobin C. Harding)
b1490a26ea Move enables_absolute_lock_time method (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
The term "final" is an archaic Bitcoin term however it is well used, it exists in Bitcoin Core code as well as in various bips. To help folks new to Bitcoin add documentation to the `is_final` method including historical notes.
Note, this does _not_ deprecate `is_final` - while writing the notes I found the term "final" in enough official places that I think its fair game to keep the term, some things people just have to learn, we can definitely help with that learning though.
Fix: #1198
ACKs for top commit:
Kixunil:
ACK a762a89b48
apoelstra:
ACK a762a89b48
Tree-SHA512: 895fbdce90223d90c0a68fb1e3d6b7aada4a3606d1294ea4df1f4194681a79d970b0434e7bb078f6d5cbf413b3550e72560d6d5cf811a5a959adf53f7f778ab2
8c0e5213d3 Delegate debug for ScriptBuf to Script (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
Currently the derived implementation of `Debug` for `ScriptBuf` prints the inner vector of u8s as integers, this is ugly and hard to read. The `Script` implementation of `Debug` prints the script opcodes and data as hex, we can just delegate to it.
With this applied we get debug output of form:
Script(OP_DUP OP_HASH160 OP_PUSHBYTES_20 3bde42dbee7e4dbe6a21b2d50ce2f0167faa8159 OP_EQUALVERIFY OP_CHECKSIG)
Fix: #1516
ACKs for top commit:
Kixunil:
ACK 8c0e5213d3
apoelstra:
ACK 8c0e5213d3
Tree-SHA512: ca07d9fb191f4e0379cbd96b2944e6881094a8334d39b97209b6bf452a3c15d4aede53b9c88176b9b7667b7a539d47897940bc561dc9f8cd83ce1990a08047e1
1d3d5a9c5b Take Into<secp256k1::PublicKey> in PublicKey constructors (Tobin C. Harding)
b13a76407b keys: Clean up test imports (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
We can make the API more ergonomic by taking a generic argument that implements `Into<secp256k1::PublicKey>` in the `bitcoin::PublicKey` constructors.
The only thing than this is useful for is passing in `KeyPair` and the `From` implementation already exists. Add a unit test to verify.
Fix: #1453
## Note
As per the discussion in #1453 I checked secp and bitcoin for all keys that can be converted using `From` and it turns out its only `KeyPair` which already has `From` impls - good rust-bitcoin devs :)
ACKs for top commit:
Kixunil:
ACK 1d3d5a9c5b
apoelstra:
ACK 1d3d5a9c5b
Tree-SHA512: b5e5272561de15cdcfb15913aa5d42ddc96bf2fd5835068a5a9aa0274074ffa698ec9e81707f102b7d1b244f1abd0fdbd0eb4b6b505c84c3d5719dcb01d46efb
49e8b8da32 Use write_all for sighash encoding (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
From BIP143:
> If sighash type is SINGLE and the input index is smaller than the number of outputs, hashOutputs is the double SHA256 of the output amount with scriptPubKey of the same index as the input;
Currently we are using a `Sighash` which wraps double sha256 so while technically correct this means we are relying on `Sighash` to implement `Encodable`. We can remove this requirement by directly using the `sha256d::Hash` type to hash the outputs data.
Fix: #1549
ACKs for top commit:
Kixunil:
ACK 49e8b8da32
apoelstra:
ACK 49e8b8da32
Tree-SHA512: 8dd0037245a7cf180ba8a6eceeadad912d4adc14fc3f49df9008856de262624666d7d575195eea4868b2a5252dc565590e6be78471053b5e6367f3d2363310e8
e7bbfd3913 Improve Psbt error handling (DanGould)
Pull request description:
## Separate `encode::Error` and `psbt::Error` recursive dependency
This initial work attempts to fix#837's first 2 points
> - The current psbt::serialize::Deserialize has an error type of consensus::encode::Error. I think we should cleanly separate consensus encoding errors from application-level encoding errors like psbt.
> - There is a recursive dependence between encode::Error and psbt::Error which would need to be cleanly dissected and separated so that there is no dependence or only one-way dependence.
## Better `ParseError(String)` types
arturomf94 how compatible do your #1310 changes look to address #837's third point with this design?
> - There are a lot ParseError(String) messages that could use a better type to downflow the information.
I think your prior art would completely address this issue now.
## On handling `io::Error` with an associated error
`encode::Error` has an `Io` variant. now that `Psbt::deserialize` returns `psbt::Error` and produces an `io::Error`, we need an `Io` variant on `psbt::Error`. Except that doing so breaks `#[derive(Eq)]` and lots of tests for `psbt::Error`.
Kixunil, I'm trying to understand your feedback regarding a solution to this problem.
> I believe that the best error untangling would be to make decodable error associated.
> I meant having associated `Error` type at `Decodable` trait. Encoding should only fail if the writer fails so we should have `io::Error` there (at least until we have something like `genio`).
>
> > [it] is a problem to instantiate consensus::encode::Error in [the psbt] module for `io::Error`?
>
> It certainly does look strange. Maybe we should have this shared type:
>
> ```rust
> /// Error used when reading or decoding fails.
> pub enum ReadError<Io, Decode> {
> /// Reading failed
> Io(Io),
> /// Decoding failed
> Decode(Decode), // consensus and PSBT error here
> }
> ```
>
> However this one will be annoying to use with `?` :( We could have `ResultExt` to provide `decode()` and `io()` methods to make it easier.
>
> If that's not acceptable then I think deduplicated IO error is better.
Kixunil didn't we just get rid of Psbt as `Decodable`? Would this make more sense to have as an error associated with `Deserialize`? Or did we do the opposite of what we should have by making Psbt only `Serialize`/`Deserialize` because of #934, where only consensus objects are allowed to be `Decodable`? I wonder if we prioritized that strict categorization and are stuck with worth machinery because of it. My goal with #988 was to get to a point where we could address #837 and ultimately implement PSBTv2.
ACKs for top commit:
tcharding:
ACK e7bbfd3913
apoelstra:
ACK e7bbfd3913
Tree-SHA512: 32975594fde42727ea9030f46570a1403ae1a108570ab115519ebeddc28938f141e2134b04d6b29ce94817ed776c13815dea5647c463e4a13b47ba55f4e7858a
44d3ec487d Rename Payload::as_bytes to inner_prog_as_bytes (sanket1729)
a446df583c Make Payload non-exhaustive (sanket1729)
6ebc9de252 Introduce WitnessProgram struct and cleanup Address validity invariants (sanket1729)
41652caf05 Introduce is_spend_standard method (sanket1729)
Pull request description:
Fixes#1561.
Highlights:
- Segwitv0 programs with lengths apart from 20 or 32 are invalid `Address` struct. Such Addresses are useless and we should not parse/create them.
- Renamed `is_standard` to `is_spend_standard`.
ACKs for top commit:
apoelstra:
ACK 44d3ec487d
tcharding:
ACK 44d3ec487d
Tree-SHA512: 1ee36f7ea25c65619ddf7d643d025690096876843dbe6fbdf877ce23e88049d79b0bbd78cee6cf4b415bca028b3634bb70c9f52d1098bd90558e6ba7f8731332
Addresses with Segwitv0 not having len 20/32 are invalid and cannot be
constructed. Also cleans up a API bug in
ScriptBuf::new_witness_prog(ver, prog) allowing prog of invalid lenghts.
ebfbe74243 Implement `Debug` for generic `Address<V: NetworkValidation>` (Jiri Jakes)
Pull request description:
Previously `Debug` was implemented for both `Address<NetworkChecked>` and `Address<NetworkUnchecked>`, but not for cases when the `NetworkValidation` parameter was generic. This change adds this ability. Based on Kixunil's tip.
With previous implementation, the `test_address_debug()` resulted in error:
The added `Debug` on `NetworkChecked` and `NetworkUnchecked` are required by compiler.
---
While dealing with derives and impls, I also attempted to turn all the derives on `Address` into manual impls (see Kixunil's suggestion in https://github.com/rust-bitcoin/rust-bitcoin/pull/1489#discussion_r1052448057). The motivation behind this was the possibility to remove derives on `NetworkChecked` and `NetworkUnchecked`, too. However, even with manual impls, all the traits on `NetworkChecked` and `NetworkUnchecked` were still required by compiler in this sort of situations (see also the rest of the same discussion linked above). I do not fully understand why, perhaps limitation of this way of sealing traits?
It can be demonstrated by removing `Debug` derivation on `NetworkUnchecked` and `NetworkChecked` in this PR and running `test_address_debug()`.
Therefore, if we want to allow users of the library to define types generic in `NetworkValidation` and at the same time derive impls, it seems to me that `NetworkChecked` and `NetworkUnchecked` will have to have the same set of impls as `Address` itself.
ACKs for top commit:
Kixunil:
ACK ebfbe74243
tcharding:
ACK ebfbe74243
apoelstra:
ACK ebfbe74243
Tree-SHA512: 87f3fa4539602f31bf4513a29543b04e943c3899d8ece36d0d905c3b5a2d76e29eb86242694b5c494faa5e54bb8f69f5048849916c6438ddd35030368f710353
We can make the API more ergonomic by taking a generic argument that
implements `Into<secp256k1::PublicKey>` in the `bitcoin::PublicKey`
constructors.
The only thing than this is useful for is passing in `KeyPair` and the
`From` implementation already exists. Add a unit test to verify.
Fix: #1453
Currently the derived implementation of `Debug` for `ScriptBuf` prints
the inner vector of u8s as integers, this is ugly and hard to read. The
`Script` implementation of `Debug` prints the script opcodes and data as
hex, we can just delegate to it.
With this applied we get debug output of form:
Script(OP_DUP OP_HASH160 OP_PUSHBYTES_20 \
3bde42dbee7e4dbe6a21b2d50ce2f0167faa8159 OP_EQUALVERIFY OP_CHECKSIG)
Fix: #1516
The term "final" is an archaic Bitcoin term however it is well used, it
exists in Bitcoin Core code as well as in various bips. To help folks
new to Bitcoin add documentation to the `is_final` method including
historical notes.
The `bip158` module uses a `HashSet` and in order to do so requires the
`hashbrown` dependency for "no-std" builds.
We can replace the usage of `HashSet` with a `BTreeSet` in `bip158` and
remove the `hashbrown` dependency entirely.
This patch makes no claims about performance cost or benefit of this
change. The patch also makes no claims about the validity of the current
`HashSet` usage.
The `hashbrown` dependency and `HashSet` usage can be trivially added
back in if someone comes up with perf data to back it up.
Previously `Debug` was implemented for both `Address<NetworkChecked>`
and `Address<NetworkUnchecked>`, but not for cases when the
`NetworkValidation` parameter was generic. This change adds this
ability.
In preparation for deprecating the `is_final` method; move the
`enables_absolute_lock_time` method to be directly above the `is_final`
method.
Refactor only, no logic changes.
`Sighash` does not need to implement `Encodable` because it is
claimed (I don't know exactly myself) that `Sighash` is never consensus
encode in Bitcoin.
We are currently relying on `Sighash` to implement `Encodable` when
encoding creating the segwit v0 sighash for a single input.
For reference, from BIP143:
If sighash type is SINGLE and the input index is smaller than the
number of outputs, hashOutputs is the double SHA256 of the output
amount with scriptPubKey of the same index as the input;
We can use `write_all` directly to write the hashed bytes and remove the
implementation of `Encodable` from the `Sighash` type.
While we are at it, use `write_all` to write the zero hash also to make
the code more uniform and understandable.
Fix: #1549
70fe07f1ce Export the DisplayHex trait from within prelude (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
We use `internals::hex::display::DisplayHex` in many places, we can improve ergonomics of the `internals` crate by re-exporting it from the `prelude` module.
ACKs for top commit:
Kixunil:
ACK 70fe07f1ce
apoelstra:
ACK 70fe07f1ce
Tree-SHA512: 96a89135cb0b829b7b5926a3b344f78e178b5b48e772a69da5133fab6d2e14e7b7bbaa56b7a417a5c1a64337546a1c7bac32307d3a1f27aa199ed61f590902bf
a7dd4b5ab0 Add a rustdoc test to Denomination (Tobin C. Harding)
Pull request description:
Add a rustdoc test to the `Denomination` type to show basic usage.
ACKs for top commit:
Kixunil:
ACK a7dd4b5ab0
apoelstra:
ACK a7dd4b5ab0
Tree-SHA512: 08f15c4641e70f043276b873e60fcf0e195fe50b6c5c18a245d2d609f4a4a4badc291aae1be532fc4890a91b2057cd308c86d0d3b85770b600a07499303a7bc4
Recently we introduced some mutation testing to the `pow` module but
testing is never done - add more `mutate` attributes and add unit tests
to ensure all mutants are killed.
Of note, the `from_compact` and `to_compact_lossy` functions are not
done, doing so results in a bunch of surviving mutants.
Parsing addresses from strings required a subsequent validation of
network of the parsed address. However, this validation was not
enforced by compiler, one had to remember to perform it.
This change adds a marker type to `Address` that will assist the
compiler in enforcing this validation.
We use `internals::hex::display::DisplayHex` in many places, we can
improve ergonomics of the `internals` crate by re-exporting it from the
`prelude` module.
1b0988833a Remove `ToHex` (Martin Habovstiak)
Pull request description:
The `ToHex` trait was replaced by either simple `Display`/`LowerHex` where appropriate or `DisplayHex` from `bitcoin_internals` which is faster.
This change replaces the usages and removes the trait.
ACKs for top commit:
tcharding:
ACK 1b0988833a
apoelstra:
ACK 1b0988833a
Tree-SHA512: a1b508e24ac247a0692c01b7cb1e7fa8f23fbfa3d6c3d5dfe669eec01f940a96c3f88508cb0b2e3529eebd9cb51e7d41435dbd5f4cbaf3bc14b9c7e7d790308b
a400757676 Add failing tests from serde-json (sanket1729)
b3246bf73f Fix LeafVersion serde (sanket1729)
Pull request description:
The default implementation maps to visit_u64. The current implementation
does not roundtrip with many deserializers, including serde_json. See
the failing test in the second commit
ACKs for top commit:
Kixunil:
tACK a400757676
tcharding:
ACK a400757676
Tree-SHA512: a6307b799b0bb4af398addc9ddbff0d811b632d1cc6ab4bdd77aaf3f151e48dd1cd10e3f90a71ef8fc3feb1cd988f7a719f92ec745b5fdf2ae0f0ad97ab2fa10
The `ToHex` trait was replaced by either simple `Display`/`LowerHex`
where appropriate or `DisplayHex` from `bitcoin_internals` which is
faster.
This change replaces the usages and removes the trait.
94b678e73f Rename `push_scriptint` and make it private (Martin Habovstiak)
Pull request description:
`push_scriptint` is a significant footgun with an unclear name. This renames it and unpublishes to avoid mistakes by downstream crates.
Closes#1517
ACKs for top commit:
apoelstra:
ACK 94b678e73f
Tree-SHA512: 9e1772c6fb326d8b0c78d702ad9926a79a91589feb8650aed7c5e75bfbdbf0164357b4d5b190877c40b8469e0e3be3d3453fe407741b5dae0c5758176f756417
Tobin C. Harding
Andrew Poelstra
Arturo Marquez
sanket1729
Jiri Jakes
bnabi
DanGould
Martin Habovstiak
