public
/
git-sig
5
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

add more background on alternatives

This commit is contained in:
Lance Vick 2020-11-17 16:37:13 -08:00
parent 03e1a595f7
commit 7e347abbae
Signed by: lrvick
GPG Key ID: 8E47A1EC35A1551D
1 changed files with 36 additions and 9 deletions
Show Stats Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

45
README.md
View File

@ -143,12 +143,9 @@ anyway.
In spite of many popular claims to the contrary, PGP is still the most well In spite of many popular claims to the contrary, PGP is still the most well
supported protocol for distribution, verification, and signing for keys held supported protocol for distribution, verification, and signing for keys held
by individual humans. It is also the only protocoal with wide HSM support by individual humans. It is also the only protocol with wide HSM support
allowing you to keep keys out of system memory and requier physical approval allowing you to keep keys out of system memory and require physical approval
for each operation. E.G a trezor, ledger, or yubikey. for each operation. E.G a trezor, ledger, yubikey, etc.
Popular alternatives like signify or straight openssl have poor support for
these workflows.
Admittedly the GnuPG codebase itself is a buggy dated mess, but PGP as a spec Admittedly the GnuPG codebase itself is a buggy dated mess, but PGP as a spec
is still Pretty Good for many use cases. A recent modern rewrite by a number is still Pretty Good for many use cases. A recent modern rewrite by a number
@ -157,6 +154,36 @@ stable future.
See: https://sequoia-pgp.org/ See: https://sequoia-pgp.org/
The only promising alternative to GnuPG for software signing that has hsm ### Why not "notary" ?
support and the very attractive feature of expiring signatures is [The Update Framework](https://theupdateframework.io) which may be supported as an alternate method in the future
if m-of-n multisig is ever implemented. Notary is very well designed and well supports many HSMs.
It may be worth supporting as an alternate method in the future if m-of-n
multisig is ever implemented as a part of the TUF specification which has been
on their TODO list for a few years now.
It has the very desirable feature of conditionally expiring signatures which
no other solution has at the time of this writing, which comes from it being
purpose built for software signing concerns.
See: [The Update Framework](https://theupdateframework.io)
### Why not straight "openssl" ?
Openssl has HSM support via OpenSC that is fairly well supported via PKSC#11.
Contributions suggesting this an alterantive backend to OpenPGP are welcome,
however they would have to also come with methods for key discovery and pinned
key groups via configuration files of some kind.
PGP gives us these features almost for free.
### Why not "signify", "age", or "crev" ?
These alternatives have poor if any support for HSM workflows and thus put
private keys at too much risk of theft or loss to recommend for general use at
this time.
That said, verifying folders/repos that use these methods is certianly of value
and contributions to support doing this on systems where those tools are
available are welcome.